What Moved
The US Federal Reserve cut rates for the third time in 2019 on October 30, bringing the benchmark to 1.50-1.75%. Chair Powell signaled a pause, calling the current stance "appropriate" (Fed, Oct 30, 2019). For investors evaluating private market returns, the year's rate trajectory had created an increasingly favorable yield environment.
The Bank of Canada held at 1.75% on October 24 — now above the top of the Fed's range for the first time since the early stages of the Fed's hiking cycle. The BoC acknowledged softer global conditions but maintained that the Canadian economy was close to potential (BoC, Oct 24, 2019).
The federal election on October 21 returned the Liberals to power with a minority government. Markets reacted calmly — the result was largely expected and didn't signal dramatic policy shifts for housing or financial regulation.
Canadian housing continued to recover. Toronto sales were up 14% year-over-year in October, and prices were rising again. The stress test, while still in place, was no longer suppressing demand as severely as in 2018 (TRREB, Oct 2019).
What It Means
Three Fed cuts in four months, while the BoC held firm, created an unusual policy divergence. Canadian rates were now higher than US rates across the curve — a dynamic that had several implications for private market investors.
For private credit, the BoC's hold was modestly positive. Higher Canadian rates meant MIC borrowers were paying rates that reflected actual economic conditions rather than emergency accommodation. Lending margins were healthy, and borrower demand remained strong.
The housing recovery was the more significant development for private real estate investors. After 18 months of stress-test-driven adjustment, the Canadian housing market was finding its footing. Rising sales and prices supported existing MIC loan collateral and created new origination opportunities. For investors in private real estate funds or development financing, improving fundamentals were a tailwind.
The minority government outcome was neutral for private markets. No major regulatory changes to housing policy or alternative investments in Canada were expected in the near term. The political stability provided a constructive backdrop for continued private market deployment heading into year-end.
What We're Watching
With the Fed signaling a pause and the BoC holding, the near-term rate outlook was stable. The question for 2020 was whether this stability would hold or whether global conditions would force further action.
The housing recovery's durability was worth monitoring. If the reacceleration continued through winter, it could reignite concerns about housing affordability and speculative behavior — potentially bringing regulatory attention back to alternative lending.
Year-end PE deal activity typically picks up as sponsors push to close transactions. Canadian mid-market deal flow heading into Q4 would provide a read on the health of the PE market heading into 2020.
Closing
October brought a rare convergence: political certainty, rate stability, and housing recovery. For Canadian private market investors, it was a constructive setup heading into the final months of the year. The open question was whether these favorable conditions would carry into 2020.
For the full quarterly analysis, see Q4 2019: Canada's Housing Bubble Warning.
Alts Insider provides educational content for Canadian accredited investors. This is not investment advice. Always consult qualified professionals before making investment decisions.