Hedge Funds & Liquid Alternatives

Introduction

Most investors own stocks that go up when markets rise and down when markets fall. Hedge funds and liquid alternatives offer something different — strategies that can profit (or at least protect capital) in both directions, using tools unavailable to traditional mutual funds.

For Canadian investors, this asset class presents unique considerations. True hedge funds are available through exempt market channels, while regulated "liquid alternative" funds (introduced in 2019) provide similar strategies within the mutual fund framework.

This guide explains what hedge funds actually do, how they differ from liquid alternatives, the risks and benefits of each, and how Canadian investors can access these strategies.

What Are Hedge Funds?

Hedge funds are private investment pools that use strategies beyond simple buy-and-hold. The "hedge" in hedge fund originally referred to hedging — reducing risk through offsetting positions. Today, it broadly describes any alternative investment strategy using tools like:

Short selling: Profiting when prices fall
Leverage: Borrowing to amplify returns
Derivatives: Options, futures, swaps for exposure and hedging
Concentration: Large positions in fewer holdings
Illiquid investments: Securities that don't trade easily

Hedge funds are typically structured as limited partnerships, available only to accredited investors, with limited liquidity (quarterly or annual redemptions) and high fees.

The Traditional Fee Structure

Hedge funds famously charge "2 and 20":

2% management fee on assets under management (annual)
20% performance fee on profits (often with a hurdle rate and high-water mark)

This means a fund earning 10% gross delivers ~6.4% net after fees:

10% gross return on $100 = $10
2% management fee = -$2
20% of remaining $8 profit = -$1.60
Net to investor = $6.40

Fee pressure has reduced some managers to "1.5 and 15" or similar structures, but hedge fund fees remain high compared to traditional investments.

Hedge Fund Strategies

Hedge funds span a wide spectrum from low-risk to very aggressive. Understanding the strategy is essential.

Equity Strategies

Long/Short Equity The most common strategy. Managers buy stocks they expect to rise (long) and short stocks they expect to fall. The "net exposure" (longs minus shorts) determines market sensitivity.

Net long (e.g., 70% long, 30% short): Still directional, rises with markets but with reduced volatility
Market neutral (e.g., 100% long, 100% short): Aims for returns uncorrelated to market direction
Net short: Rare, positions for market declines

Returns: 5-10% target with lower volatility than equity markets Risk: Stock selection, short squeezes, factor exposure

Activist Investing Taking large positions in companies and pushing for changes — asset sales, management changes, capital returns, or strategic shifts.

Returns: 10-15% target Risk: Concentrated positions, event-driven outcomes

Event-Driven Strategies

Merger Arbitrage Buying shares of acquisition targets and shorting acquirers to capture the spread between current price and deal price. Profits if deals close; loses if deals break.

Returns: 4-8% target, bond-like but with occasional large losses Risk: Deal breaks, regulatory blocks, financing failures

Distressed/Special Situations Investing in troubled companies — buying debt at a discount, participating in restructurings, or positioning for turnarounds.

Returns: 10-15%+ target with high volatility Risk: Bankruptcy outcomes, legal complexity, illiquidity

Relative Value Strategies

Fixed Income Arbitrage Exploiting pricing discrepancies between related fixed income securities — different maturities, issuers, or structures.

Returns: 4-8% target Risk: Leverage-dependent (small spreads require leverage for meaningful returns), duration mismatches

Convertible Arbitrage Buying convertible bonds while shorting the underlying equity to isolate the option value.

Returns: 5-8% target Risk: Credit risk, volatility changes, liquidity

Macro Strategies

Global Macro Making directional bets on macroeconomic trends — currencies, interest rates, equity markets, commodities. This is the strategy of famous managers like George Soros and Ray Dalio.

Returns: Highly variable, 8-15%+ target Risk: Directional bets can be very wrong; high volatility

Managed Futures (CTA) Systematic trend-following strategies, typically using futures contracts across asset classes. Quantitative models identify and ride trends.

Returns: Variable; performs well in trending markets (especially during crises) Risk: Choppy/mean-reverting markets cause whipsaw losses

Multi-Strategy

What it is: A single fund combining multiple strategies, allocating dynamically based on opportunity.

Examples: Citadel, Millennium, Point72

Returns: 10-15%+ target with lower volatility than single strategies Risk: Complexity, key person risk, less transparency

Liquid Alternatives in Canada

In January 2019, Canadian securities regulators introduced "Alternative Mutual Funds" (commonly called liquid alternatives or liquid alts). These funds can use hedge fund-like strategies within a regulated mutual fund wrapper.

What Liquid Alts Can Do

Compared to traditional mutual funds, liquid alts can:

Short sell up to 50% of NAV
Use leverage up to 300% gross exposure (through borrowing and derivatives)
Hold illiquid assets up to 10% of NAV
Concentrate positions more than traditional funds

Key Differences from Hedge Funds

| Factor | Hedge Funds | Liquid Alternatives | |--------|-------------|---------------------| | Regulatory status | Exempt market (OM) | Prospectus-qualified mutual fund | | Investor eligibility | Accredited investors only | All investors | | Liquidity | Quarterly or longer | Daily redemption | | Minimum investment | $25K-$500K+ | Often $500-$5,000 | | Transparency | Limited disclosure | Full prospectus disclosure | | Leverage limits | None (strategy-dependent) | 300% gross max | | Short selling limits | None | 50% of NAV max | | Fees | Typically 2 and 20 | Typically 1-2% MER, sometimes performance fee | | Tax treatment | Trust/LP flow-through | Mutual fund trust |

Why This Matters for Canadians

Liquid alts democratized access to alternative strategies. Before 2019, using shorting or significant leverage required either:

Accredited investor status (to access hedge funds)
Self-directed derivative trading (requiring expertise)

Now, any Canadian investor can access long/short equity, managed futures, and other strategies through their regular brokerage account.

However: Regulatory constraints mean liquid alts are typically less aggressive versions of hedge fund strategies. A hedge fund might use 4x leverage; a liquid alt is capped at 3x. A hedge fund might run 100% short; a liquid alt is capped at 50%.

Risk Analysis

Strategy-Specific Risks

Short selling risks:

Unlimited loss potential (stock can rise infinitely)
Short squeeze risk (forced covering drives prices higher)
Borrow costs and recall risk

Leverage risks:

Amplifies losses as well as gains
Margin calls can force liquidation at worst times
Funding costs reduce returns

Derivative risks:

Counterparty default
Basis risk (hedge doesn't perform as expected)
Liquidity risk in stressed markets

Structural Risks

Liquidity mismatch: A hedge fund with quarterly redemptions holding illiquid positions may struggle to meet redemptions in stressed periods. Gates (limits on redemptions) can trap investors.

Key person risk: Many hedge funds depend on one or two key decision-makers. Their departure or distraction can materially impact returns.

Operational risk: Hedge fund operations are complex — prime brokerage relationships, margin management, derivative documentation. Failures can result in significant losses.

The "Hedge Fund Crisis" Pattern

Hedge funds have a history of spectacular blowups:

LTCM (1998): Leverage + liquidity mismatch
Amaranth (2006): Concentrated natural gas bets
Various funds in 2008 financial crisis
Archegos (2021): Hidden leverage through swaps

The pattern: leverage + concentration + stress = catastrophic loss. Diversification across managers is essential.

Performance Reality Check

Do Hedge Funds Deliver?

Aggregate hedge fund performance has underwhelmed over the past 15 years:

HFRI Fund Weighted Composite Index (broad hedge fund benchmark) has underperformed the S&P 500 in most recent periods
Average hedge fund returns have been 4-8% annually since 2010 — less than simple stock/bond portfolios

However:

Top-decile managers consistently generate alpha
Hedge funds may outperform during market downturns (2008, 2022)
Risk-adjusted returns (Sharpe ratio) may be competitive even when absolute returns are lower

The Access Problem

The best hedge funds are often closed to new investors or require relationships and scale most individuals can't provide. The funds available to retail accredited investors may not represent the best the industry offers.

When Alternatives Add Value

Hedge fund and liquid alt strategies work best as:

Volatility reducers: Lower portfolio volatility without proportional return reduction
Diversifiers: Returns uncorrelated to stocks and bonds
Crisis hedges: Some strategies (managed futures, macro) historically profit during equity drawdowns

They work poorly as:

Return enhancers: Chasing hedge fund returns typically leads to expensive underperformance
Replacements for equities: In bull markets, alternatives often lag stocks

How Canadian Investors Can Access These Strategies

Through Your Advisor (Registered Exempt Products)

Traditional hedge funds available through EMDs:

CI Alternative Funds
Picton Mahoney Fortified Funds
Various single-manager funds

Requirements: Accredited investor status, EMD relationship Minimums: Typically $25,000-$100,000+

Through Your Brokerage (Liquid Alternatives)

Prospectus-qualified funds available to any investor:

Purpose Diversified Real Asset Fund
Mackenzie Global Long/Short Equity
Dynamic Alpha Performance Fund
AGF Global Opportunities Fund
CI Liquid Alternatives
PIMCO Managed Futures Strategy

Requirements: None (general retail access) Minimums: Standard mutual fund minimums ($500-$5,000)

Through ETFs

Some liquid alternative strategies are available as ETFs:

Horizons Managed Futures Index ETF (HMF)
Purpose Diversified Real Asset Fund (PRA)
Various US-listed alternative ETFs accessible to Canadians

Requirements: Brokerage account Minimums: Cost of one share

Fund of Hedge Funds

Diversified exposure across multiple hedge fund managers:

Reduces single-manager risk
Provides access to funds that might otherwise be closed
Adds another fee layer

Requirements: Usually accredited investor status Minimums: Often $100,000+

Due Diligence Framework

For Hedge Funds

Strategy understanding:

Can you explain how the fund makes money?
What market conditions favor or hurt the strategy?
What's the expected return and volatility?

Manager evaluation:

Track record (audited, verified)
AUM and growth trajectory
Team depth and stability
Operational infrastructure

Terms analysis:

Fee structure (management, performance, hurdle, high-water mark)
Liquidity terms (redemption frequency, notice period, gates, lockups)
Capacity (is the fund accepting new capital?)

Operational due diligence:

Administrator (independent NAV calculation)
Auditor (reputable firm)
Prime broker relationships
Compliance infrastructure

For Liquid Alternatives

Fund mandate:

What strategies does the fund use?
How does it compare to hedge fund versions?
What are the regulatory constraints?

Performance attribution:

Where do returns come from?
How has it performed in up/down markets?
What's the correlation to equities and bonds?

Cost analysis:

MER (management expense ratio)
Any performance fees?
Trading costs (turnover)

Portfolio Role and Allocation

How Much to Allocate?

Institutional investors typically allocate 10-25% to alternatives (including hedge funds). For individual investors, 5-15% may be appropriate, depending on:

Risk tolerance
Investment horizon
Access to quality managers
Overall portfolio diversification needs

Implementation Approaches

Core-satellite: Keep 70-80% in traditional stocks/bonds (core) and 20-30% in alternatives (satellite) for diversification.

Risk parity inspiration: Use alternatives to balance risk across asset classes, potentially reducing equity allocation while maintaining return expectations.

Tactical: Add managed futures or macro as portfolio hedges during periods of elevated equity risk.

Canadian Tax Considerations

Hedge funds (LP structures): Income is typically taxed as it's earned at the fund level, flowing through to investors. Character (interest, dividends, capital gains) is preserved.

Liquid alternatives (mutual fund trusts): Distributions are taxed as ordinary income, dividends, or capital gains depending on character. Short-term trading may generate more ordinary income than buy-and-hold funds.

RRSP/TFSA eligibility: Liquid alternatives are generally eligible. Hedge fund eligibility varies by structure.

Key Takeaways

Hedge funds use tools unavailable to traditional funds — shorting, leverage, derivatives, concentration. This enables different return patterns, not necessarily higher returns.
Liquid alternatives brought these strategies to retail investors in Canada since 2019. They're regulated, liquid, and accessible — but also constrained compared to true hedge funds.
Strategy matters more than the "hedge fund" label. Long/short equity behaves differently than macro behaves differently than managed futures. Understand what you're buying.
Fees significantly impact net returns. A fund earning 8% gross but charging 2 and 20 delivers ~4.4% net. Compare to alternatives carefully.
Access to top managers is the challenge. Average hedge fund performance has disappointed. If you can't access top-decile managers, liquid alternatives may offer comparable value at lower cost.
Use alternatives for diversification, not return chasing. These strategies add value by providing uncorrelated returns and downside protection — not by beating equity markets.
Both channels are available to Canadians: exempt market hedge funds through EMDs (accredited investors), liquid alternatives through any brokerage (all investors).

This guide is educational content only. It does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation of any specific security. Consult a registered advisor before making investment decisions.

Related guides in this series: